When a phone call from the obstetrician's office goes to the wrong person . . . Elizabeth Schmidt can't figure out why her husband doesn't seem excited about the news she's sure he heard. Is he unhappy? Or is James cheating on her? Pastor Jay Davidson is in shock. Bethany Schmidt, the woman he's in love with, is pregnant. Should he walk away, or is God asking him to play the part of Joseph in real life and not just in the church Christmas program? Bethany can't figure out why Jay is acting so weird. Has he figured out one of the two secrets she's keeping until after Christmas? Can a ponytailed itinerant carpenter with a pet chicken help unravel the confusion?