Five years after returning to Stears Branch, at the crossroads of their lives, Gary and Carrie take wrong turns. Believing only what their eyes tell them, they find themselves in a world of "If only's." Gary follows a woman promising to help him find his father, when she pulls him into organized crime and money laundering a phony bourbon venture, his old buddy carries tales of infidelity to Carrie. The rift grows wider when she turns to a stranger for comfort. Trust is broken. It takes the threat of an old enemy seeking revenge to bridge that gulf.